Internment limits 1942 ?

The italicized questions are answered by ChatGPT in the non-italicized portions.

were there any geographical limits on Roosevelt’s interment order?

President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s Executive Order 9066, issued on February 19, 1942, authorized the internment of individuals of Japanese descent, as well as some German and Italian Americans, during World War II. The order itself did not specify exact geographical limits but instead empowered military commanders to designate “military areas” from which people could be excluded.

In practice, the entire West Coast of the United States was targeted, including:

• California (the entire state)
• Western Washington
• Western Oregon
• Southern Arizona

These areas were deemed critical to national defense and vulnerable to sabotage. Approximately 120,000 Japanese Americans—two-thirds of whom were U.S. citizens—were forcibly relocated from these areas to internment camps further inland, located in states such as Utah, Wyoming, Colorado, and Arkansas.

German and Italian Americans were also affected, but their internment was more selective and less systematic.

---

Did Colorado’s refusal to comply with this order have any measurable effect?

The resistance of Colorado Governor Ralph Carr to the internment of Japanese Americans was significant in principle, though it did not prevent the broader enforcement of Executive Order 9066. Carr was one of the few politicians who publicly opposed the internment and welcomed Japanese Americans to Colorado, stating that denying their rights was un-American. His stance had both immediate and long-term effects:

Immediate Effects

     1. Relocation to Colorado: Carr allowed Japanese Americans to settle in Colorado, including those released from internment camps. Some came voluntarily to avoid internment elsewhere, while others were relocated to the Amache Internment Camp (Granada War Relocation Center) in southeastern Colorado, which was one of the ten internment camps established by the federal government.

     2. Backlash from Constituents: Carr faced significant political backlash for his stance. Many Coloradans were hostile to Japanese Americans, fearing economic competition and sabotage, mirroring sentiments prevalent on the West Coast. This opposition likely contributed to his loss in the 1942 Senate race.

Long-Term Effects

     1. Legacy of Civil Rights Advocacy: Carr’s principled stand earned him a lasting reputation as a defender of civil rights. Although his political career was effectively ended, he became a symbol of integrity and courage. Decades later, he was posthumously honored for his actions, including having a justice center in Denver named after him.

     2. Community Building: Carr’s willingness to accept Japanese Americans helped create a small but resilient Japanese American community in Colorado, some of whom remained in the state after the war.

While Carr could not stop the enforcement of Executive Order 9066, his resistance highlighted the moral opposition to the policy and provided a rare safe haven during a dark chapter in U.S. history.

References

Information about Colorado Governor Ralph Carr’s resistance to Japanese American internment is well-documented in several sources. Here are key references where you can find comprehensive details:

1. Books:

      • “Colorado’s Japanese Americans: From 1886 to the Present” by William M. Hosokawa.

This book details the experiences of Japanese Americans in Colorado, including Ralph Carr’s role in supporting the community during internment.

      • “A Principled Politician: The Ralph Carr Story” by Adam Schrager.

This biography provides a detailed account of Carr’s actions, his opposition to internment, and his enduring legacy as a civil rights advocate.

     2. Documentary:

      • “The Untold Story of Ralph Carr and the Japanese: Fate of 3 Japanese Americans and the Internment” (2012).

This film examines Carr’s role and the broader history of Japanese American internment, with a focus on Colorado.

     3. Primary Sources and Historical Records:

      • Archives at the Amache Preservation Society (associated with the Granada War Relocation Center).

These archives include detailed records of Japanese American internment in Colorado and Carr’s efforts.

     4. Online Resources:

      • The Colorado Encyclopedia article on Ralph Carr offers a concise summary of his resistance and its impact.

     • The Densho Encyclopedia also has an entry on Carr, providing context within the larger history of Japanese American internment.

---